Both carrom and chess have been able to hold the spot of one of the most favoured indoor games of many people across the world. Both of these games have gained enough popularity in the world (especially in India and in other South Asian countries). Now, some like to play carrom more than chess while others like chess more than carrom. So a conflict occurs between carrom and chess lovers, right? You might think which game is best, carrom or chess?
Considering the fun aspect, carrom is the best game because you can play with many people together. But chess offers more quality than carrom. It sharpens memory, helps improve cognitive skills and logical reasoning and many more. So considering the benefits, chess is the best game.
Here is a quick comparison table highlighting which game is better among carrom and chess.
|Many people can play together||Only two people can play at a time|
|Improves hand-eye coordination||Improves critical thinking|
|Less future options||More future options|
|Improves concentration||Improves concentration and memory|
Now this was a short comparison between both games. Continue reading because in depth comparison is given below along with pros and cons of both the games. I can bet, you’ll really enjoy reading this post. So without further ado, let’s dig in!
- Many People can play together
Carrom is really fun to play. You really enjoy playing this game with your family members and friends. Basically you can make team with your friends and beat the opposite team and enjoy a lot. Carrom helps to cultivate a sense of bonding between the players in this way.
Whereas in chess, the whole game is played in mind. It is a very silent game. Only two players can play. So will not have great fun as carrom unless you love to play chess like me 🙂
- Improves hand-eye coordination
In carrom you have to aim the coins you want to strike with your striker. So the player having a good hand-eye coordination can only play better. The whole carrom game is based on the hand-eye coordination principle. Playing more and more carrom, this skill improves.
In chess, there is no such importance or use of hand eye coordination. However chess has many other benefits which we are going to discuss later in this post.
- Improves concentration
When you can focus your mind, body and soul on one thing for a long time then that is concentration.
This was the definition of concentration in simple words and carrom definitely helps to improve it. When you play carrom, you get very much involved in the game (provided you love to play it!). Focusing on the game, on your each turn your only motive is to win. Therefore you concentrate in the game.
Thus, knowingly or unknowingly you improve your concentration playing the game of carrom. However in case of chess, more concentration is required. You have to calculate each of the possible moves of your opponent and then only you make your move. You have to think of possible situations and act accordingly in chess. Thus great mental work is required while playing chess compared to carrom. Hence chess win in this criteria.
- Less future options
Although carrom playing has some pros, there are some cons as well. I know that for a carrom lover it is hard to listen this. But basically there are not that options available considering that you can build your future on carrom.
You can become professional carrom player and compete in tournaments. But actually popularity is very less in carrom. So it is very hard to build up your future in carrom. On the other hand chess has more wider options than this.
- Sometimes can take you off track
Carrom doesn’t offer you quality as chess. Have you ever heard of any school including carrom in their school curriculum? But chess is included. Because chess is very crucial especially for brain development and overall academic improvement.
Apart from hand eye coordination, fun and improving concentration I don’t see much importance of playing carrom. Rather carrom can take you off track.
What I mean to say is, if you play solely for entertainment purpose then it is good. But if you get addicted then you will eventually tend to skip your academics. You might get in touch of bad friends while playing the game. This bad friends can spoil you and divert you. Probably the time when you need to focus on studies, you might get off-track and end up in misery.
So far we discussed about carrom, now let’s have some talk about chess.
- Improves memory
Chess improves and sharpens your memory. Here is an article where I wrote the importance and worthiness of learning chess. You can check that out.
Chess is beneficial in improving memory. Even mental patients are suggested to play chess. In fact it is proven that chess can reduce the risk of alzheimer’s disease, depression and anxiety. You can check this post to see the health benefits of playing chess.
- Improves concentration
Chess improves concentration and takes it to the next level. Since your mind is involved a lot your brain is constantly tested on each move you make. Actually you can’t even win the game unless you concentrate properly.
One interesting thing to note that playing chess you burn a lot of calories. So you can imagine the level of brain activity is going on when you are playing chess.
- Improves logical thinking
You start thinking logically as you play more and more chess. If you haven’t played any chess game yet, you can test this by playing some. You will definitely notice the improvement in your logical thinking.
This logical improvement happens because playing chess you learn to think of every chess moves logically. While making any move you decide and reason yourself whether you should make that move or not. Thus you train and improve your reasoning skill.
- Improves problem solving ability
Each move you make while playing chess becomes a challenge for you. After thinking properly and anticipating each and every possible moves you make your move accordingly to solve this challenge. As you play chess naturally you face lot of challenges and problems. Thus, this increase your problem solving skills.
Also these logical thinking and problem solving ability improvements make many chess players good at maths as well.
- Increases imagination power
You will easily be able to imagine the things in 3D. This will help you to get an extra edge in learning geometry and physics where spatial imagination skill is required.
When you play chess the game is going on in your mind. When you calculate the moves you actually imagine them in your mind. Moreover you continue to play chess for a long time and get success in achieving mastery in it. Then you can even play blindfold chess. Many GMs like Magnus Carlsen can play blindfold chess.
- Improves confidence
Chess is being played by intellectual people. So when you play chess and become good at it you gain a different kind of confidence from inside. You start thinking yourself smart. Chess actually makes you smarter.
It is not that people who doesn’t play chess are not smarter. Actually chess help you in achieving that and gives you an extra edge. When you win any chess game you gain confidence. But even if you lose you learn a lot from it. You then correct your mistakes and improve as a better chess player. This goes on in cycle.
- More future options
There are many options available to build your future in chess. You can become a professional chess player, a chess coach, an arbiter, a chess programmer, a chess journalist and much more…
- If you don’t like it- you might find it boring
You can enjoy any game only if you like it!
Basically, if you don’t love playing chess then you will definitely get bored. You will definitely get frustrated just looking at those 64 squares and 32 chess pieces on the chess board.
In carrom you are physically involved playing the game. You strike the coins with striker. You hear the striking sounds of the coins. Thus these subtle things make you more connected with the game as soon as you start.
Moreover other team members keep on commenting and passing jokes while playing. So that really keeps you engaged and intrigued in the game. But in chess only two players play that too in silent atmosphere and it might bore you. Other than this, i don’t find any other con of playing chess.
Chess is no doubt the best game. Carrom as source of entertainment and time pass is good. But considering the benefits chess offers it is the clear winner.
It is important to note that which game is best is a very subjective choice. I considered chess as the best considering all the criterias discussed above. Ultimately which game is best depends which one you like the most. So that’s it!
Hope you enjoyed reading this article 🙂 Please do share if you found this helpful!
Do people outside India play carrom?
According to Wikipedia carrom originated in India. This game is played worldwide. But it is mostly popular in India and its neighbouring countries along with some other South Asian countries. However it has gained some popularity in Europe, Australia and North America where it has been introduced by people of Indian origins.
Is carrom more popular or chess?
Chess is more popular than carrom. According to YOUGOV, about 70% of the adult population of the UK, US, Germany, Russia and India, played chess at some point of time in their life.
Which game originated first carrom or chess?
As per wikipedia chess first originated in the 6th century in India. While there is very little information about when exactly carrom originated. Some say 18th century or some say older than that. But there is no exact evidence.
Hi! I’m Pritam and I’m a huge chess enthusiast! I know the actual problems that chess players face. I created this site to make chess easy to understand for newcomers, and also to help players of all levels of ability to improve their chess playing skills. Read more about me here.